Don’t Close Your Eyes Read online

  CRITICAL ACCLAIM FOR

  CARLENE THOMPSON

  “Her style is richly bleak, her sense of morality complex . . . Thompson is a mistress of the thriller parvenu.”

  —Fear

  DON’T CLOSE YOUR EYES

  “Carlene Thompson creates smart, interesting characters the reader cares about within a gripping suspense story.”

  —Judith Kelman,

  author of After the Fall

  IN THE EVENT OF MY DEATH

  “In the Event of My Death is Carlene Thompson’s blood-chilling new tale of vengeance, madness and murder.”

  —Romantic Times

  THE WAY YOU LOOK TONIGHT

  “Thompson . . . has crafted a lively, entertaining read . . . skillfully ratchet[ing] up the tension with each successive chapter . . .”

  —The Charleston Daily Mail

  She picked up the handset of the cordless phone and pressed TALK. “Hello.”

  Nothing.

  “Hello.”

  Finally Natalie heard a long sigh. “Na-ta-lie.”

  Female voice, soprano, sweet, breathy.

  A prank, obviously, but her heart beat a little harder. “This is Natalie. What do you want?”

  “Na-ta-lie.”

  The sweet voice caressing her name. Uneasiness tingled through her. “If you don’t tell me what you want, I’m hanging up.”

  Another sigh. Then the gentle voice. “Their throat is an open tomb.”

  Natalie drew a sharp breath. “What is THAT supposed to mean?”

  “You’ll find out soon.”

  Click. Silence.

  Natalie stared at the handset as if it were a snake. A chill passed through her as she realized the voice had sounded exactly like Tamara’s.

  ST. MARTIN’S PAPERBACKS TITLES

  BY CARLENE THOMPSON

  Share No Secrets

  All Fall Down

  If She Should Die

  Black for Remembrance

  Since You’ve Been Gone

  Don’t Close Your Eyes

  In the Event of My Death

  Tonight You’re Mine

  The Way You Look Tonight

  DON’T

  CLOSE

  YOUR

  EYES

  CARLENE

  THOMPSON

  NOTE: If you purchased this book without a cover you should be aware that this book is stolen property. It was reported as “unsold and destroyed” to the publisher, and neither the author nor the publisher has received any payment for this “stripped book.”

  DON’T CLOSE YOUR EYES

  Copyright © 2000 by Carlene Thompson.

  All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews. For information address St. Martin’s Press, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010.

  ISBN: 0-312-97576-7

  EAN: 80312-97576-0

  Printed in the United States of America

  St. Martin’s Paperbacks edition / November 2000

  St. Martin’s Paperbacks are published by St. Martin’s Press, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010.

  15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6

  To all my dogs, who have given me joy,

  inspiration, and unconditional love throughout the years.

  Thanks to my patient and supportive agent, Pamela Ahearn.

  Special thanks to William E. Johnston, D.V.M., for technical advice and excellent care of the Thompson animals.

  DON’T

  CLOSE

  YOUR

  EYES

  1

  SATURDAY NIGHT

  Tamara dried the last crystal wineglass, held it up to the fading summer light shining through the kitchen window, and nodded. Spotless. She hated spots on glasses, particularly crystal. Tomorrow night, when Warren came home from his conference in Cleveland, they’d share a bottle of Chateau Latour Blanche on their sixth anniversary. Tamara was not a wine connoisseur, but he’d assured her the Latour Blanche was expensive and should be properly appreciated. When she’d fussed about spending a lot of money on a bottle of wine, he said it was a gift from a patient. Tamara knew better than to ask which one. Warren was a psychologist and never discussed his patients.

  Tamara looked around the pristine kitchen. The whole house was spotless. With no children and no job, she had more than enough time to keep the house perfect.

  Tonight, however, she had nothing left to clean. She’d even reorganized the kitchen cabinets and put down fresh shelf paper. She could work on her latest quilt, the lovely one with the hummingbird design she’d created, but she wasn’t in the mood. She could drop by the headquarters of the suicide hotline Warren had forced her to organize, but tonight she didn’t want to hear any sad stories. She didn’t enjoy Saturday night television and she felt too restless to read. Usually she took an evening walk, but a storm was predicted.

  Tamara looked out the window and sighed. Daylight Saving Time extended light until nine o’clock. So far it was a lovely evening, a bit cloudier than usual, but still nice. Surely the storm wouldn’t hit for over an hour. That left plenty of time for a walk.

  She grabbed an old white sweater off the coat tree beside the back door. It was mid-June, but Port Ariel, Ohio, sat on the edge of Lake Erie, which sent cool breezes off its water all year. The comfortable temperature was what drew so many tourists to the beach area every summer. Warren hated tourists, but Tamara spent most of her time at home and rarely had contact with them. Besides, they were good for local business and therefore good for her twin sister Lily, who owned a successful antique store downtown. Tamara was making the hummingbird quilt for Lily’s shop. “People like old furniture but not old bedding. Only bedding that looks old,” Lily always said. “I could sell three times the number of these gorgeous quilts you make!” Tamara was pleased by their popularity, but she never increased her production. Haste made for sloppy work.

  As she automatically locked the back door and descended the porch steps, Tamara glanced at her watch. Eight-thirty. Warren always called promptly at ten when he was out of town. She frowned. She mustn’t be late for the call. Things were rocky between them. Warren had been irritable, quiet, and aloof for months. Tamara felt he was disappointed that she hadn’t been able to give him a child, although he never mentioned it. Lily contended that Warren didn’t want a child—not everyone did. Tamara told her sister she was being ridiculous.

  To be twins, they were so different, hardly like sisters at all except for their looks and their love for each other. Lily wasn’t even religious in spite of their strict Catholic upbringing. Ignoring Lily’s good-natured skepticism, Tamara had begun attending mass every day, praying for the child that would draw Warren back to her. Now she knew her prayers had worked. Her periods were always irregular, but this time she was over a month late. She’d taken a home pregnancy test this morning and she had wonderful news for Warren, which she’d save until tomorrow evening when he returned.

  Humming beneath her breath, Tamara crossed the lawn and walked down Hyacinth Lane, a wide dirt road running north through a wooded area. She delighted in the towering oaks, locust trees, and scattered dogwoods and crab apples. When the dogwoods and crab apples were in bloom, this place seemed like a fairy world.

  She took a rubber band out of her sweater pocket and pulled back her long blond hair in a ponytail. Delicate silver filigree earrings set with amethyst stones swayed in the breeze, tickling her neck. She tilted back her head, closed her eyes, and drew a deep breath. Clean, clear air tinged with the scent of approaching rain and the water of Lake Erie filled her delicate nostrils. When she was young, she and Lily had spent countless
hours on the lake in their parents’ cabin cruiser and their sleek twenty-foot inboard motorboat. The girls were excellent water-skiers. Warren went out with the family sometimes on the cabin cruiser, but he always stayed on board. He didn’t even fish.

  Something rustled in the underbrush. Naturally timid, Tamara grew motionless, her gaze scanning the sides of the road. She knew the sound probably came from a small animal. Most of them were perfectly harmless except for poisonous snakes, although there weren’t many of those around. Besides, a snake wouldn’t make so much noise and it certainly wouldn’t attack unless threatened.

  Her mind knew this. Her body didn’t. She felt cold, imagining a sleek head rising up to bury venom-filled fangs in the skin of her ankle.

  The rustling grew louder. Tamara stiffened. She was ready to turn and dash for home when a large dog burst from the greenery on her left. It bounded to her, panting.

  “Well, hello there!” Tamara exclaimed, laughing in relief. This was the fourth evening in a row she’d seen the dog on her walk. It had wiry black-and-tan hair, mostly black, and seemed to wear a perpetual smile. She called it “Happy Face.” Showing no fear of humans, the dog approached her on slender tan legs with white paws, its curled tail wagging. Tamara bent to pet it. She had no idea what breed it was, but she thought it would be beautiful if it were bathed. Instead its hair was matted and slightly oily. It wore no collar, and a fresh scratch ran down the right side of its tan face.

  Poor thing, Tamara thought. She’d love to have the dog, but Warren had firmly pronounced they could not take it in. He didn’t like animals. The dog was so endearing, but it was getting thinner. She decided to buy dog food tomorrow. At least she could keep the dog well fed even if she couldn’t give it a home.

  Happy Face walked beside her for a while, glancing up as if for approval. Wild violets grew along the edges of Hyacinth Lane. Tamara stooped and picked a few while the dog waited patiently. A slate-gray catbird emitted its lonely mewing call to the evening. A few ambitious fireflies were already hard at work, blinking gaudily against the darkening sky.

  Tamara looked at her watch again. 8:45. She should return home. She could be bathed and ready for bed by the time Warren called. She smiled. When she was ready for bed, Lily would be ready for a night at trendy Panache. Their old friend Natalie St. John was back in town and Lily wanted to show her a good time. She’d invited Tamara along, but Tamara declined, telling her she would be waiting for Warren’s call. “You’re hopeless,” Lily had teased. “I might get married some day but I’ll never be as settled as you. Hovering around the phone at ten for a husband?” Apparently Lily thought hovering only justified in cases of handsome, unpredictable boyfriends.

  The dog looked up at her expectantly. She’d forgotten their game. “Okay, Happy Face.” Tamara bent and picked up a stick. The dog shifted from paw to paw in anticipation. Tamara threw the stick far into the trees. The dog shot after it. Usually it returned in less than a minute with the stick, which it dropped at her feet. This time Tamara heard it barking. The barking grew fainter. Obviously it had spotted a rabbit and was giving chase. At least she hoped it was a rabbit. She didn’t want to be greeted by a dog reeking of skunk.

  She stood on the road for a few minutes. Up ahead reared the remains of Saunders House built back in the early nineteenth century when Port Ariel was called Winthrop. When the senior Saunderses died, their beautiful daughter Ariel became the lover of Captain Zebediah Winthrop, whose father had founded the town. Ariel was labeled a “scarlet woman” after she gave birth to Zebediah’s son Thaddeus out of wedlock. In his youth Zebediah had been forced to marry a homely crab of a woman inaptly named Mercy. While Zebediah sailed Lake Erie, Mercy and her pious friends delighted in wreaking petty vengeances on Ariel and the baby, terrorizing the young mother. Then, when Thaddeus was barely one year old, Captain Winthrop’s ship, the Mercy, caught fire and foundered on the shore near Ariel’s house. Ariel had spotted the wreck from her widow’s walk and rushed to the rescue, single-handedly saving two injured sailors and her beloved Zeb from drowning.

  Mercy died shortly afterward, mostly from bitterness and jealousy and pure meanness, people claimed. She was barely in the ground when Zebediah married Ariel. Most citizens had forgiven her in light of her bravery and did not object when Zebediah changed the name of the town in her honor. Together they had two more children. Zeb died long before Ariel and she had a large monument built to him in the town square. Although she lived to be eighty, she never remarried.

  As children Tamara and Lily were entranced by the story of Ariel who had lived alone on the windy shore of Lake Erie, tormented yet strong and loving. They thought she was beautiful, wonderful, courageous, and all that a woman should be. Unbeknownst to their parents, they used to dress up and play for hours in the Saunders house, taking turns at pretending to be Ariel. Sometimes Natalie St. John played with them. Tamara had seen pictures of Ariel and thought that with her long black hair and dark eyes, Natalie made the best Ariel, but she never told Lily. Natalie was the only one of their friends with whom they shared the secret of the game. Natalie could always be trusted with a secret.

  For just a moment Tamara had an impulse to forge ahead and take a look at the decrepit house. Then she glanced up. Dark clouds billowed. The summer storm was blowing in faster than she’d expected. She had no time for exploring now. She’d left several of her windows up and her new car in the driveway beneath a tree instead of in the garage.

  Tamara turned and took several hurried steps down Hyacinth Lane. Tree limbs swayed and creaked. A silvery shaft of lightning ripped the gray sky. Tamara’s ponytail blew wildly in the wind and a piece of dirt flew into her right eye. She stopped, rubbing at it gently. Damn. It had lodged under a contact lens.

  A tear ran down her cheek. Lord, it hurt. She shut her eye and took a few more hurried steps. A scrabbling sound pulled her up short. She jerked her head to the right. What on earth was that? It sounded as if it were rushing at her.

  “Happy Face?” she called. “Happy, is that you?”

  The rushing sound stopped. Now there was silence, but a sinister silence. Something was watching her. She could feel the gaze running up and down her body. Her hands turned icy. She took a deep breath. Don’t be silly, Tamara, she told herself sternly. What would be watching you? A chipmunk? A squirrel? Still, a dark wing of fear fluttered inside her. “Happy Face?” she called again, hopefully, uncertainly.

  But it wasn’t the dog. Suddenly footsteps pounded through the underbrush, snapping vines, then smacking against the bare dirt. Tamara whirled blindly, not sure in which direction to run. It didn’t matter. In a flash an arm shot out from a slick, dark mass. Some kind of plastic coat. Tamara yelped in fear as the arm clenched around her neck and yanked backward. She dropped the violets she’d picked earlier. Her heels dragged the ground. She clawed uselessly at the sinewy arm locked directly under her chin. Her neck felt as if it were going to snap. Her eyes bulged in fear and shock as she gasped for air. “Wha—”

  A long steel razor with a bone handle flicked open. In one cold, frozen moment Tamara saw the blade glint in a flash of lightning before it slashed viciously across her throat and around her neck, cutting the vocal cords, severing the carotid artery. Blood spurted straight out, then cascaded down, drenching the sleeve of her white sweater.

  “Their throat is an open tomb,” a voice whispered caressingly in her ear as Tamara’s slender body jerked grotesquely in its death throes.

  The arm released Tamara. She fell in a heap, still twitching, her eyes wide, her blood soaking the dirt. The figure kneeled beside her and tucked a note into the fold of her sweater. Then it stood, bowed in a grotesque imitation of servitude, and wafted silently back into the dark, swaying forest.

  Rain had begun to fall when the dog returned five minutes later. It loped toward Tamara, then abruptly stopped, dropping the stick. It whimpered unhappily. Finally it warily approached the body of the woman who earlier had greeted it so joyously. Wh
en it smelled blood, the hair on its back stood up and it crouched, half-crawling to Tamara. It stared at her with warm amber eyes, the smiling look gone from its face. Gently, almost reverently, it lay down and stretched its sleek neck across the gaping slash in hers, protecting her from further harm. As rain poured, the dog howled mournfully into the lonely night.

  2

  I

  SUNDAY MORNING

  Natalie slowly opened her eyes. Morning sun filtered dimly through delicate willow-patterned curtains. A beautiful green coverlet lay over her drowsy body. She drew a deep, lazy breath, then shot up in bed, her dark gaze frantically searching for the clock. Nine! She was due at Anicare an hour ago. She was on the Sunday morning shift. What had happened to the alarm?

  Reality rushed back. She closed her eyes in relief and leaned back against the pillows. She wasn’t at Anicare because she was officially on vacation—on vacation from her job, on vacation from Kenny Davis. She was back in Port Ariel in her old room and unless her nose deceived her, she smelled bacon and eggs frying.

  Natalie stretched, yawned, considered going back to sleep for a few minutes, then thought of the breakfast being prepared for her. Under normal circumstances breakfast consisted of a bagel or an English muffin eaten on the run.

  She was swinging her legs out of bed when her father yelled, “Natalie, breakfast! Hurry up before I eat it all!”

  She smiled wryly. He’d been saying the same thing since her mother left twenty-three years ago when Natalie was six. He’d always seemed to think cooking breakfast for her could make up for any emotional trauma—a runaway mother, a faithless lover.

  “Be right there, Dad,” she called, looking around the room for her robe. It lay on the white bedroom chair, a beautiful splash of pale green-and-pink silk. She wished desperately she had brought another robe. She’d grabbed this one because it fit neatly into the suitcase, but just looking at it caused her pain. She’d been so touched when she’d opened the package last Christmas morning and found the exquisite kimono-style robe she’d admired in a store a month before. She didn’t think Kenny had been paying attention.